I am white. Male. Raised Catholic. We must take responsibility for our actions.
Much of the news coverage over the last few days has been on the most recent Anti-Asian violence. A white male (and yes, it’s almost always a white male) murdered eight people in the Atlanta area. Most of the people killed were Asian women.
Although I grew up in a predominantly white town and worked in predominantly white businesses, some of those most dear to me are Asian, either as immigrants, as native born U.S. with Asian heritage, or as continued residents in their home Asian nations. I see their pain, even if I’m not the target of what causes their pain. In fact, I fit the demographic that is most likely to contribute to, rather than alleviate, that pain.
Some of my Asian friends (see note) have felt the discrimination directly, others less so. One friend’s parent still living overseas calls more frequently to “check up,” feeling more anxious for the safety of their Asian American child. Another friend lives in constant anxiety. They had taken their parents out of an assisted living arrangement soon after the COVID pandemic began, fearful that they might become exposed to the virus that has taken so many in that system. Those parents recently got vaccinated, but still fear going out in public because of the attacks on Asian Americans, especially the elderly. Another friend moved back to Asia because of the heightened bigotry in the U.S. Yet another friend is the child of an Asian mother and White American father on military assignment, literally abandoned on the streets in their native country, and, after being adopted into a loving family, faced years of bigotry here in America. Psychological strain is evident even when there is no physical attack.
A conservative-leaning (as opposed to “conservative”) friend, who also happens to be of Asian descent, correctly pointed out to me that Anti-Asian violence is not new, nor is it exclusively perpetrated by white people. That is true. There has been a history of Asian-African American conflict in the U.S. for a long time, with both sides guilty of bigotry. Some of it may be home-grown, but some of it is a reflection of historical European/American interactions with Asia (much of which has not been positive) and pressure to secure a place in the white-dominant caste system in the U.S.
That conservative friend also got it right when they pointed out that bigotry against Asians in this country has been common in our history. Chinese immigrants, for example, came to the U.S. in the mid-1800s seeking their fortunes in the gold rush. Some were conned, kidnapped, and/or forced into exploitive arrangements, then and continuing today under “modern” trafficking crimes. When gold riches didn’t pan out for them, as with many Americans moving westward, the Chinese labored for the railroad companies, again in a largely exploitative arrangement. Later the U.S. passed the Chinese Exclusion Acts. In World War II there were the Japanese internment camps. More violence against Asians followed the U.S. involvement in the Korean and Vietnam “conflicts” as refuges made their way to the United States. Anti-Japanese violence occurred in the 1970s as American factory workers felt competition from “cheap Japanese radios.” Clearly this isn’t a new phenomenon. Even the mythology of the “model minority” is bigoted and exploitative.
As with so many mass murders, there is a tendency to dehumanize the victims when the murderer is a white male. The Georgia Sheriff updating reporters on the murders, when asked about the perpetrator, noted: “They got that impression that yes, he understood the gravity of it. He was pretty much fed up, and kind of at [the] end of his rope, and yesterday was a really bad day for him and this is what he did.” You would think that the eight people murdered also had a bad day. So did millions of other people who didn’t murder eight people, and he apparently intended to continue his bad day by driving to Florida to murder other people. The sheriff also noted the perpetrator indicated he was trying to remove “the temptation” of the women’s presence. Language is powerful. By writing off the heinousness of the act, and putting the onus on those who were killed for why the murderer killed them, the sheriff is dehumanizing the victims of that act.
Dehumanizing the victims is a standard fallback. White people who vote against their interests are said to be experiencing “economic uncertainty” even though their votes exacerbate that uncertainty. In reality, the system favors whites; it always has. Voting differently would actually better address any of their valid concerns. So what is being covered up by this phrase? The same as it always has been. In our national history we quickly found that diminishing leaders of Native American civilizations as “savages” while setting up a system to cheat them gave us rationalization for pushing them further and further, and farther and farther, into untenable positions. We dehumanized African Americans through slavery, Jim Crow, segregation, criminalization policy, and more. We dehumanize “Mexicans,” who are mostly Central American refugees seeking escape from chronically corrupt regimes, along with migrant workers. We dehumanize Muslims, the LGBTQ community, and any other “other” we identify, simply to “keep them in their place,” that is, not interfere with our white privilege. We’ve done it throughout our history, and we continue to do it today.
What is new is the specific reason for this current wave of Anti-Asian violence. While the numbers are a moving target, there have been statistics like “there has been a 150% increase” or “3000 violent attacks” over the last few months. Let’s not kid ourselves. This is entirely due to the racist, Anti-Asian rhetoric spewed by Donald Trump and the Republican party. There is a reason Trump intentionally and repeatedly referred to the coronavirus that causes COVID as the “Chinese Virus,” ignominiously using his infamous black Sharpie to emphasize the point. He, and his Republican co-conspirators, intentionally used bigotry as a weapon to ignite the flames of passion in their followers. Because for the Republican party, bigotry works.
This isn’t new. “Conservatives” (again, as opposed to conservatives) have used bigotry to keep white workers in line against the “others” throughout our history, knowing that it distracted poorer whites from focusing on the oligarchy that manipulates the economic system in their favor. “Conservatives,” i.e., plantation slaveowners, argued that free states were attacking their right to enslave others, playing it up to the white farmers left destitute by the slave system as “northern aggression.” “Conservatives” screamed “socialism” in the 1860s and 1870s during Reconstruction, using the exact arguments that are used by today’s “conservatives.” John C. Calhoun’s mantra lives on in today’s oligarchs. Every time “others” manage to get a little bit more of the Constitution to apply to all Americans, not just the wealthy white ones, “conservative” forces pushed back. When Reconstruction threatened to give equality to former slaves, “conservatives” created Jim Crow laws and the KKK, and erected statues as intimidation. When the Supreme Court deemed segregation in schools unconstitutional and the civil rights movement was gaining steam, “movement conservatives” fought back by naming schools after slaveowners and instituting redlining to block equality of opportunity for African Americans. As soon as it became clear that Barack Obama could become president, “conservative” oligarchs invented the backronym “TEA Party” to provide cover for racist attacks (birtherism, Anti-Muslim, etc.). In other words, they did what they have done over and over again through our history. Want to know why Fox News has spent so much time lying about Dr. Seuss, and Mr. Potato Head? Because it is a tried-and-true culture war distraction from reality to rile up the bigotries of “conservatives.” And it keeps working.
Which gets me back to the beginning. While everyone must do their part, there is an extra responsibility for us white people. We have controlled the government, the airwaves, the economics, the public sentiment for the entire history of our nation. Often we’ve exploited our minority partners in this great experiment in self-government we call democracy (yes, technically we’re a republic, let’s not get distracted here). Whether white males like it or not, we’re slowly becoming inclusive. There’s a reason for that. It’s because the ideal of our nation requires it. That ideal is what has attracted immigrants from around the world. It’s what we should all be striving for.
The bottom line is that this is a nation of immigrants. Like most white Americans, I take pride in my English, Irish, and Portuguese heritage. My Asian friends, LatinX friends, African American friends, friends of all stripes and identities, all take pride in their heritages as well. But like me and virtually all of us, they also take pride in being American. We want America to be worth striving for. In allegorical terms, Abraham Lincoln’s statement that “In giving freedom to the slave, we assure freedom to the free” applies to today. We are all freer when we ensure our Constitution applies to all Americans.
Lincoln also said: “We are not enemies, but friends.” He called for us to be “again touched, as surely they will be, by the better angels of our nature.”
Those better angels require us to take responsibility for our history, and our present. To quote another historical figure, “With great power comes great responsibility.” We are the power to be the change we need to be, if only we are brave enough to be it.
[Note: I’m being intentionally vague here for both privacy and safety reasons. For any given friend, Asian can mean Chinese, Japanese, Korean, Vietnamese, Southeast Asian, South Asian, and other Asians. Of course, violence isn’t restricted to that against Asians, and these views, and our responsibility, applies to all of us.]
[Photo credit from https://www.glamour.com/story/anti-asian-hate-crimes-are-on-the-rise-heres-what-you-can-do-about-it%5D
David J. Kent is an avid traveler, scientist, and Abraham Lincoln historian. He is the author of Lincoln: The Man Who Saved America, Tesla: The Wizard of Electricity and Edison: The Inventor of the Modern World as well as two specialty e-books: Nikola Tesla: Renewable Energy Ahead of Its Time and Abraham Lincoln and Nikola Tesla: Connected by Fate.
Check out my Goodreads author page. While you’re at it, “Like” my Facebook author page for more updates!
Lightness Traveling said:
Having a technical background, I’m inclined to make assessments based on numerical data. I also tend to look at the big picture… what’s actually behind something, or what drives the data. As anyone who works with data has had hammered into thinking, “Correlation is not the same as causality.” That people who eat more nuts tend to live longer doesn’t mean that nuts cause people to live longer. Perhaps people who can afford to eat nuts can also afford better health care? Aside from that, I can only base personal opinions upon my own experience. So…
I live in a fairly “working class”, region. Think: probably half of the vehicles on the road are pickup trucks (mine included), and half of those are Diesel. Remember when oil was -$34 per barrel and it was going to be the end of fossil fuels? Just looking around a little, the big picture encouraged a buy order for Exxon Mobil. Likewise, I’m not all that swayed by the superficial coverage of most “news” outlets. Personally, I haven’t had a single anti-Asian encounter locally… ever. I have occasionally heard of instances from others, but it’s rare. Probably my worst experience personally was once being labeled, “…one of those smart Chinese,” by another student while in college. Just for the record, nothing worthwhile is easy.
I am who I am; so I can’t say with any authority what it’s like to be someone who looks, or who thinks differently. And there are victimized populations in the US. I just hope that adopting the mentality that one is automatically a victim because of something that she or he cannot change doesn’t cause people to give up on what this country can offer. As you may realize, I have some choice where to live. And so far at least, I choose to live here.
Regarding this terrible news story, there’s no way of knowing the motive of the clearly crazy person who just murdered these eight women. Maybe this was just a young man with psychological problems who had a bad experience with a sex-worker? And I suspect that the reason that six of the women were Asian is due to the nature of sex-trafficking in the US (Japan also). This is probably the bigger story here. Who were these women, and why were they working in these places? The statistics and the first-hand stories about the sex-trafficking of predominantly Southeast-Asian women in the US is horrifying. I strongly encourage Americans to learn about this problem. And I hope this isn’t lost in the current trend to label everything as having to do with race or ethnicity.
As somewhat of an aside, “Asian” is almost meaningless in terms of race or ethnicity in the US. The president of the local “Asian Republicans’ Association”, who is Filipino-American, jokes that it covers everyone from Israel to Japan, and Singapore to Siberia, and every skin-color, religion, economic status, and socio-political system… as well as almost two-thirds of the earth’s population.
LikeLiked by 1 person
davidjkentwriter said:
All good points, as always. I’m glad that you haven’t experienced any anti-Asian discrimination, except for the one mentioned. I’m actually the minority in my neighborhood, with various Asian heritage people a significant percentage. As far as am aware, there hasn’t been any significant anti-Asian violence around my local area, in part for the same reasons there hasn’t been any around yours.
And yet there has been violence, and there has been the terrorism caused by that violence, probably not unlike the constant fear of African Americans that they will be pulled over for something minor or imagined, with literal life or death always a potential outcome. I haven’t experienced that chronic anxiety personally, but people close to me have. While it’s certainly true that “correlation isn’t the same as causality” (as I have so often said myself), causality is often correlated. Words do matter. The fact that those words are so often carefully chosen via political and communications consultants demonstrates that fact.
I suspect you know that I understand that “Asian” in itself is meaningless. As I mentioned in my note at the bottom of the post, I used the generic term intentionally. My friends and acquaintances fall into such a wide variety of heritages that it would be cumbersome to list them all, although the main goal was to avoid identifying specific people for their own privacy.
And yes, I too encourage all Americans to learn about the problem and not to label meaninglessly. As they do learn, they will see that labels are sometimes correlated with actions.
Keep safe and healthy. And thanks for always being so thoughtful in your responses.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Lightness Traveling said:
Thank you, David. Up front, I want to apologized for hijacking this post with this comment. Feel free to delete this if you feel so inclined. I won’t take any offense.
Noticing that most media seem to be sticking to the “hate-crime” narrative regarding the news you linked here (despite law-enforcement having already determined that was not the motive) as opposed to the humanity of the victims, I really do want to emphasize that the women who were murdered were very likely being trafficked. Slavery still exists right here in the United States, and much centers around the trafficking of immigrant women for the purpose of what the FBI labels “Commercial Sex Acts”.
Of several trafficked Asian women who I have known over the last two decades, their stories are all similar… promises of domestic, hotel, tourism, or low-skill service jobs that will pay far more than they could possibly earn at home. After arriving, however, they are told that they would have to first “work off” debts in the tens-of-thousands of dollars. Then they are threatened, assaulted, and used for profit. Personally, I would like to know more about these women who were killed, and if they left behind any family. Often, that’s the whole motive for coming here in the first place.
I’ll add here that statistically, Black and White women who are US born are a majority in these statistics. However, Asian-women-in-a massage-business fits a typical pattern where the women were brought to the US with the intent of someone profiting from commercial sex.
I won’t post live links, so you’ll need to replace the “[DOT]”:
dhs[DOT]gov/blue-campaign/what-human-trafficking
pfd warning*
ucr.fbi[DOT]gov/crime-in-the-u.s/2019/crime-in-the-u.s.-2019/additional-data-collections/human-trafficking/human-trafficking.pdf
worldpopulationreview[DOT]com/state-rankings/human-trafficking-statistics-by-state
youtube[DOT]com/watch?v=bYooq32ZZ1g
LikeLiked by 1 person
davidjkentwriter said:
Thanks for emphasizing this point, which indeed is not getting as much attention in the media as it needs. The statistics are infuriating and the video was heartbreaking, but also consistent with stories I’ve heard before. My involvement has been limited, but one of the Lincoln organizations I work with has a program called “Students Opposing Slavery” (SOS) that tries to address this very real problem. It fits a pattern of exploitation that has plagued our history since the country’s inception (as well as elsewhere).
https://www.lincolncottage%5BDOT%5Dorg/learn/students-opposing-slavery/
This opinion piece by CNN’s Lisa Ling emphasizes why hateful rhetoric can exacerbate an existing problem. I don’t know how much of this you’ve experienced, but my personal connections have given me a glimpse into this.
https://www.cnn%5BDOT%5Dcom/2021/03/20/opinions/asian-american-racism-violence-wellness/index.html
We need to do better. Again, thanks for doing what you do on this issue.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Lightness Traveling said:
Thank you again, David. Lisa Ling is an extraordinary and genuinely humane journalist. While I don’t necessarily agree with what’s implied in some of her general statements, I have great respect for her objective explorations of some social topics rarely discussed in the US, including an American social perspective that she touches on in her article. I’m also encouraged to see “SOS”. There is a Dept. of State office that reports on human trafficking, but mostly for the purpose of international policy development. The fact that this is even something that happens at all in a 21st-century United States is just astounding to me.
(replace the “[DOT]”)
state[DOT]gov/bureaus-offices/under-secretary-for-civilian-security-democracy-and-human-rights/office-to-monitor-and-combat-trafficking-in-persons/
I have developed a very libertarian take on what a sober adult *voluntarily* chooses for one’s self. But that doesn’t mean that a healthy society can tolerate misogynistic expressions or behaviors as acceptable. Indeed, my only private article in here (which you have read) involved my response to such an overtly disrespectful, if not somewhat threatening public display. In that regard, Lisa Ling mentioned something that I very much agree with, which is the larger issue of the objectification of women. As for why Asian women would be so over-represented in this particular case is a very complex issue that spans across national boundaries, as well as across cultures. I’ve written about this, at least in part, several times here… so I’ll try to keep this under 15,000-words. Mostly, I just think it can’t be over-emphasized that all of these women were human beings, “…with loves, religious beliefs, fears, families, shortcomings, hopes.”
BTW, Lisa Ling’s article links to some other articles that are quite interesting, though I’m not sure that I necessarily interpreted them with the authors’ intents. Now, it’s time to go risk “running-while-an-Asian-woman”. Granted, I’m generally armed for bear.
LikeLiked by 1 person
davidjkentwriter said:
Hope you enjoyed your run and no bears were harmed. 🙂
I agree with everything you’ve said. I find it hard to imagine that this still happens, but then as I learn more and more about the 19th century, I realize we are still living it. Arguments and counterarguments then are exactly the same today. Our study group discussion today, ostensibly on Lincoln’s times, could easily have been (and often was) about today’s headlines. That scares me.
LikeLiked by 1 person